
"Listening requires focused attention, genuinely open without judgement and prepared to acceptance their perspective and their pain. It takes energy and patience. Your presence, a listening heart and an understanding heart is an antidote for a troubled heart." Azah Yazmin
When I read the headlines to the above story, it immediately caught my attention. I am a retired Registered Nurse/Nursing Instructor and wanted to read exactly what the author actually identified as "rude" remarks towards nurses. I wondered if I would agree with Casey Clark, the author? I thought to myself that I had probably heard every one of any possible comments listed before even delving into the article. I wasn't wrong or surprised.
I suppose I read the article through the eyes of an old nursing instructor, though. I was always hopeful of finding good learning opportunities in which to engage my students. You see, nursing isn't just a science, it is also an art. Nurses need a proper bedside manner just as physicians do. This article would be a great post-conference topic in which to use as a tool.
If I were still teaching, I would throw out each "remark" and ask them to write down their response and then share as to why they think it to be appropriate. It would help me to see who I needed to help with communication skills.
I also thought about the responses I had given in my career which spanned around thirty years of my life. So I will list my come-backs:
* "You do this for the money." Giggling a little, I would tell them in all honestly, of course that's part of it. But it also helped me with humbleness because I always went home grateful for good health and made me feel like I was doing something worthwhile in life.
* "Why didn’t you become a doctor?" In all seriousness, I would answer that "the question was a very good one," but for me, personally, I started my college life after having four kids and so time and money were an issue.
* "When will the real doctor come in?" (I am not a practitioner, so they would only ask when the doctor was coming to see them.) I would understand that they had concerns and wanted answers. I would provide them with when that particular physician "usually" made rounds, but ask them if they had any concerns that I might help them with until then.
* "I don’t want a male nurse." I am female, but as an instructor who had male students, I can answer this. Most of the time, cultural and religious beliefs dictate these standards. Sometimes, patients have other very private and personal reasons for their decisions. It's never about the nurse and forcing an ego battle. We enter a patient's world when they are at their most vulnerable state and often in pain. Respect that! End of discussion.
* "You only work three days a week?" That must be nice." Simply say, "Yes, I enjoy my work and my schedule." (And smile!)
* "I could never do your job." Sometimes people are just wanting to make conversation. But probably the best reply would be, "Oh, have you ever thought about becoming a nurse? I could tell you about some programs, if you are interested."
* "You’re just a nurse." "Yes, I am and I'd very much like to help you today. One of my duties is to advocate for you. We could start by you telling me what is the single most important goal you have so that we can accomplish that together."
Nurses see patients at their worst, so they need to see us at our best!!! Listen with your heart...
About the Creator
Shirley Belk
Mother, Nana, Sister, Cousin, & Aunt who recently retired. RN (Nursing Instructor) who loves to write stories to heal herself and reflect on all the silver linings she has been blessed with :)
Reader insights
Outstanding
Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!
Top insights
Compelling and original writing
Creative use of language & vocab
Easy to read and follow
Well-structured & engaging content
Excellent storytelling
Original narrative & well developed characters
Expert insights and opinions
Arguments were carefully researched and presented
Eye opening
Niche topic & fresh perspectives
Heartfelt and relatable
The story invoked strong personal emotions
Masterful proofreading
Zero grammar & spelling mistakes
On-point and relevant
Writing reflected the title & theme



Comments (7)
Get it Shirley! This was wonderfully insightful, lovingly witty and inspiring! I love it! 🩷
This is wonderful, and I can really relate as a retired nurse/administrator myself! I love how you've reframed these "rude" comments as teaching moments rather than insults. Your responses show exactly what good nursing is: patience, humility, and meeting people where they are. The way you handled "I don't want a male nurse" is spot on. It's never about our egos; it's about respecting vulnerability. And your answer to "just a nurse" is perfect advocacy in action. You're absolutely right that nursing is both science and art. Your students were lucky to have an instructor who understood that communication and heart matter just as much as clinical skills. Thanks for sharing this perspective. It's a great reminder of what the profession is really about!
wow
Such a beautiful perspective. Your responses show so much grace, patience, and wisdom. “Listen with your heart” is the perfect takeaway. 💙👩⚕️
Shirley, thank you. This was a very interesting and valuable read. In these past five years with my mom I have spent a good amount of time inside hospitals. I have encountered some outstanding nurses who were exactly as you were in your answers to the questions. The nurses with outstanding bedside manner were a pleasure to deal with. But, I have also experienced the other side. Nurses who were in too much of a hurry. Who wouldn’t give me a chance to talk when I wanted to ask a question they were already answering before my question was complete. I can go on and on. One time this one nurse was so horrible that I became aggressive. And I’m generally a fairly passive and easy-going person but in this instance I had to speak up and out. Thank you again I really enjoyed reading this.
My mom was a nurse for over thirty years. She would never share everything she heard directly, but her coworkers were very open about the abusive nonsense they all went through. Thank you for this.
I've worked as a Retail Nutritionist for 5 years and like rude patients, I've had rude customers too. It was a nightmare. I love how polite your answers are!