Humans logo

I DMed my first D&D game

And it actually worked

By Ruby RedPublished 6 months ago β€’ 3 min read
I DMed my first D&D game
Photo by Gian-Luca Riner on Unsplash

I recently ran a small Dungeons and Dragons standalone story, and it wasn't a complete disaster.

I know that sounds quite pessimistic and grim, but think about it: This was my first D&D session as the Dungeon Master. I was underprepared, a tad overconfident, and completely out of my depth. There were also 12 people in the party, because I am ambitious. (HEY! I managed to get 12 people, 6 complete newbies and 6 veteran players to work together. That's an achievement!)

For context to our non-D&D nerds: The DM is the one who runs the game, describes the scene and brings everything - from the players' backstories, the lore of the world, to the villain's quest of evil - together.

In other words, I put the players in a scenario with clues and situations hidden behind my descriptions and it's up to the players to find out what to fight and, I don't know, fight it, but instead get distracted by a suspiciously normal door. Yes. I said "suspiciously normal."

Despite my inexperience with DMing, sitting behind my borrowed DM screen, I felt powerful!

But being a complete control freak with a permanent writing-itch, I had decided to homebrew it. As in, not follow any pre-made storyline guides (which exist FOR first-time DMs as a way to avoid feeling trapped, lost or flailing like a baby horse). I let my creativity shine and the lore deepen and deepen - I found that it was a great outlet for all those ideas in my brain who are fighting for attention but never get used.

Let's go back to that first point though - it wasn't a complete disaster.

It wasn't.

Despite having to improvise off of my very few notes, the important stuff was there - a goal, a story, an enemy. The players followed their noses to the big boss, and despite almost running out of time (with a few animal-related distractions), it worked.

I even made a very cool prompt that brought everything together - with a poster! πŸ˜„

Introducing....

The Aquatalypse!

Poster designed on Canva by yours truly.

I made the setting a school, and the whole thing was a Oneshot - a one-off story with characters, descriptions and bosses they would never have to face again - or that had no prior connection to any prior events their characters had faced. Additionally, because of the newbie to veteran player ratio, I decided to make some modifications.

I redesigned the entire character sheet.

WOW, Red, talk about making things harder for yourself.

I tried making it more engaging, less overwhelming. I focused on simplifying the huge amount of vocab that's just "normal" when you play regularly.

To do this, I designed a "Cheat Sheet" of sorts to outline what different terms meant - like AC for Armour class- what they could do on their turn - move or use a weapon or spell - and every "check" that they could make for more information on their environment - such as perception or insight, with details on how they work.

I cut out complicated stuff like levels and multiclassing, and got them to choose their weapons, spells and cantrips (plus a few useless magical items) out of a hat, at random!

I believe it was a success. For the most part, this D&D session was a coming together of friends, a great chance to connect and be present. We played make-believe for 6 hours! We improvised with the resources we had, and escaped the absolute mayhem of right now with a weird, dystopian, post-apocalyptic, slightly underwater universe with a giant glowing squid. How awesome's that?!

Was this experience fun? Yes.

Was it wacky, weird, unexpected and chaotic? Abso-D&Ding-lutely.

Did I learn something? Yes - that I have an "I'll wait" teacher face, because 12 people talking over me is a LOT to deal with.

The consensus? D&D well and truly has its claws in me, and I'm glad, since it's something that helped me find my closest friends today. And my GOSH. More mega-respect to teachers; you have the patience of saints to deal with constant chatter and still care enough to support and nurture each student.

~

Let me know if you're curious about the Aquatalypse - I can feel a writing itch returning...

I hope you enjoyed this little story of mine!

Thanks for reading and whatnot,

- Red 🌱

friendshiphumanitypop cultureStream of Consciousness

About the Creator

Ruby Red

Heya friend, I'm Red!

I write poetry, so subscribe for a hint of vulnerability, some honesty and the occasional glimpse behind my mask 🌱

Taking a break from Vocal; focusing on my anthology πŸ«ΆπŸ’–

AI is not art.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Mother Combs6 months ago

    Oh, wow, that is an accomplishment, though. Sounds like you had fun

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

Β© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.