Hallowbridge
When a town forgets its people, everyone keeps pretending everything is normal
The Town That Forgot
The town of Hallowbridge sat in a fold of hills where the river slowed into a wide, glassy bend. In autumn the maples flamed and the air smelled of woodsmoke and apples; in winter the streets were neat with snow and the lamplight turned the drifts to gold. The town had a single main street—brick sidewalks, a hardware store with a bell that never stopped jingling, a bakery that opened at dawn, and a library whose windows always steamed in the mornings. People knew one another by the sound of their footsteps and the way they left their porches at dusk. It was the kind of place where the past felt like a neighbor you could borrow sugar from.
Mara Ellis had grown up in Hallowbridge and returned at thirty-two to care for her father after his stroke. She liked the small certainties: the barista at the bakery who remembered her order, the librarian who recommended books like old friends, the way the mayor still walked his dog past the post office. She liked the way the town fit into her hands like a familiar object.
Then, in the space of a week, things began to slip.
---
People Who Were Not There
It started with Eli Turner, who ran the clock shop on Main. Mara stopped by one rainy afternoon to ask about a watch her father had left unwound. The bell over Eli’s door chimed, but the shop was empty—rows of clocks, their faces frozen at different times, and a ledger open on the counter with a blank page where Eli’s neat handwriting should have been. Mara called his name. The rain tapped the windows. She left a note on the counter and walked home with the uneasy feeling of a missing tooth.
The next day, the bakery had a new apprentice and the barista smiled as if she had always been there. Mara mentioned Eli to the woman behind the counter. The woman blinked. “Eli? Never heard of him,” she said, and handed Mara a croissant.
Mara found the note she had left in the clock shop gone. The ledger was closed. The clocks ticked on.
Over the following weeks, more people vanished in the same way. Mrs. Kline, who taught piano and whose porch light was always on; Jonas Reed, who mended bicycles and kept a jar of marbles on his workbench; Asha Patel, who organized the summer concerts. Their houses remained tidy, their mailboxes empty, their gardens tended, but when Mara asked neighbors, when she checked the town records, there was no trace. No photographs, no obituaries, no memories. It was as if the town had been edited and the cut left no scar.
---
The Normalcy of Everyone Else
What unnerved Mara most was not the absence itself but the way the town continued. The mayor announced a harvest festival with the same practiced cheer. The librarian recommended a new mystery novel and asked Mara if she wanted a library card. Children still chased each other down the lane, shrieking with the same delighted cruelty. People greeted Mara with the same small talk, the same nods, as if the world had not been rearranged around her.
When she brought up Eli at the town meeting, the room hummed politely. “We’re lucky to have so many new faces,” someone said. “Change keeps things lively.” The mayor patted Mara’s hand. “You should rest, Mara. You’ve been through a lot with your father.” No one else remembered Eli. No one else remembered Mrs. Kline’s recitals or Jonas’s marbles.
Mara began to notice other erasures. Photographs in frames—family portraits, wedding shots—had faces that blurred at the edges when she looked too long. A mural on the library wall that had once depicted the town’s founders now showed different figures, their faces unfamiliar. The town map in the post office had a blank square where a cluster of streets used to be. When Mara traced the outline with her finger, the paper felt warm, as if it had been pressed recently.
---
Evidence That Would Not Hold
Mara tried to make proof. She took photographs with her phone; she recorded voice memos of names and dates; she wrote lists and pinned them to the bulletin board at the grocery store. Each time she returned, the evidence had been altered. Photos showed empty rooms where people had stood; voice memos played back as static; her lists had words missing, then whole lines gone. Once she found her own handwriting on a scrap of paper in the library’s lost-and-found, but the name at the top—Mara Ellis—was smudged until it read M. Ellis, and the rest of the note was a recipe for apple pie.
Her father’s memory was the only anchor she trusted. He would wake in the night and call for Eli’s clock to be wound, or hum a tune Mrs. Kline used to play. Mara would sit with him and tell him stories about the missing people, watching his eyes for recognition. Sometimes he would smile and say, “They were good neighbors,” and then, in the morning, he would ask after a neighbor Mara had never heard of.
Mara’s friend Noah, who ran the hardware store, was practical and blunt. He listened to her at first, then frowned. “You’re tired,” he said. “You need sleep. You’re seeing patterns.” He helped her search the town records and the county archives. The clerk at the courthouse typed names into a database that returned nothing. “No record,” the clerk said, and shrugged. “Weird, but not unheard of. People move.”
Noah’s skepticism was a kind of kindness. It kept the town’s machinery running. He fixed Mara’s father’s walker, lent her a ladder, and brought over soup. He did not, however, remember Eli.
---
The Shape of Grief
Mara’s grief was not the loud, communal kind. It was a private, accumulating ache that made her hands tremble when she reached for a cup. She began to catalog the missing in a notebook she kept under her pillow. She wrote down names, addresses, the color of someone’s scarf, the exact time she had last seen them. The notebook filled with neat, desperate entries. Sometimes she would wake and find pages torn out, the edges clean as if cut by a blade.
At the grocery store, she met Lena, a schoolteacher who had moved to Hallowbridge two years earlier. Lena had a laugh that made Mara think of wind chimes. She listened without judgment when Mara spoke, and for the first time in weeks Mara felt the fragile warmth of being believed. Lena agreed to help. They walked the streets together, knocked on doors, and asked questions. They found a house with a piano in the parlor and a dust sheet over it. Lena sat at the piano and lifted the cloth. The keys were yellowed but intact. She played a chord. The sound filled the room and then, in the doorway, a neighbor appeared and said, “Lovely, isn’t it? Who’s the pianist?” Lena answered, “No one. It’s been empty.” The neighbor smiled and said, “Haven’t you heard? The old Kline place was converted into a studio last year.” He had never heard of Mrs. Kline.
Lena’s belief was a small rebellion. It made Mara braver. They began to leave flowers on stoops and notes in mailboxes. Sometimes the notes remained; sometimes they vanished. Once, a bouquet of daisies they left at Jonas Reed’s workshop was gone by morning, replaced by a jar of screws.
---
The Town’s Explanation
Rumors began to circulate, as they always do in small towns. Some said the missing had left for the city. Others whispered about a developer buying up properties and remodeling them into rentals. A few older residents muttered about “the way things are now,” as if the world had always been a place where people could be unmade by convenience.
The mayor, a man with a voice like a bell, called a town forum. He spoke of resilience and community, of the need to look forward. “We cannot let ourselves be dragged into fear,” he said. “Hallowbridge is changing, and change is not always comfortable.” He proposed a committee to “celebrate our new neighbors.” The committee met in the town hall and baked cookies and made flyers. Mara stood at the back and watched people sign their names with steady hands. No one signed the names of the missing.
---
The Last Proof
Mara’s last attempt at proof was simple and stubborn. She took a Polaroid camera from the attic and, with Lena’s help, photographed the faces of everyone she could find: the baker, the librarian, the mayor, Noah, Lena herself. She wrote the names on the white borders in thick black ink and placed the photos in a shoebox. She labeled the box Hallowbridge People and buried it beneath the old oak behind her father’s house, where the roots were deep and the soil was cool.
For three nights she slept with her hand on the earth above the box, as if she could feel the faces through the dirt. On the fourth morning she dug it up. The box was there, but the photos inside were blank, the white borders empty. The ink had bled away. The shoebox smelled faintly of lavender.
Lena held Mara’s hands and said, “Maybe the town is protecting itself.” Mara wanted to ask how a town could protect itself by erasing its own people, but the words stuck like thorns.
---
The Quieting
As the disappearances continued, the town’s rhythms smoothed over the gaps. New names filled the vacancy of old ones. A food truck parked where Jonas’s bicycle shop had been; a yoga studio took the place of Mrs. Kline’s parlor. The harvest festival came and went, with lanterns and pie contests and a band that played songs no one could quite place. Mara walked through the festival with a hollow in her chest, watching faces she had photographed smile and clap and move on.
People began to look at Mara with a kind of pity that was almost tenderness. “You’re carrying a lot,” they said. “You should see someone.” They meant well. They meant to help. They could not see the missing.
One evening, Mara stood on the bridge that arched over the river and watched the water move in its slow, indifferent way. The town’s lights reflected like coins. She thought of Eli’s clocks, of Mrs. Kline’s recitals, of Jonas’s marbles, of Asha’s concerts. She thought of the shoebox and the blank photos and the way the world had been smoothed like a page with an eraser.
Noah found her there and sat beside her. He did not ask about the missing. He talked about the hardware store’s new shipment, about a leak in his roof. He reached for her hand and squeezed it. The ordinary details were a kind of mercy.
---
The Ending That Felt Like a Beginning
On a morning when the sky was the color of old porcelain, Mara woke to find a note on her father’s bedside table in a handwriting she did not recognize. It read, simply: We are fine. Don’t worry. There was no signature. Her father hummed a tune she had never heard before and asked if she had seen the new baker’s apprentice.
Mara packed a small bag. She left a note on the kitchen table for Noah—I’m going to the city for a while—and pinned it with a magnet shaped like a clock. She walked down Main Street, past the bakery, past the library, past the hardware store. People nodded. The mayor waved. Lena called after her, “Come back soon!” as if she had always been the sort to leave and return.
At the edge of town, where the road narrowed and the maples leaned in like old friends, Mara paused. She turned and looked back at Hallowbridge: the brick sidewalks, the lamplight, the river that kept its own counsel. She felt, for a moment, the weight of all the names she carried, the ones that had been taken and the ones that had been left behind.
She stepped forward.
When she reached the next bend in the road, a woman walking a dog stopped and asked a question Mara did not hear. The woman’s face was kind and ordinary. She smiled and said, “Beautiful day, isn’t it?” Mara smiled back and answered, as if nothing were wrong, Yes, it is.
Later that afternoon, Noah would tell Lena that Mara had left for the city. He would say it with the same calm certainty he used to explain a broken hinge. Lena would nod and say, “She needed a change.” The mayor would add Mara’s name to the list of people who had moved on, and the town would fold the new fact into its ledger.
In the shoebox beneath the oak, the Polaroids remained blank. On the library wall, the mural continued to show unfamiliar founders. The clocks in Eli’s shop ticked on. The river kept its slow, patient course.
And somewhere between the bend in the road and the city lights, Mara kept a small, stubborn memory of faces that no one else could see. She kept it like a secret, like a map drawn in invisible ink. It was not proof. It was not evidence. It was a thing that would not be erased: the knowledge that people had been here, that they had laughed and argued and left fingerprints on the world.
Hallowbridge went on, as towns do, arranging itself around the holes. People smiled and baked and mended and made plans. The missing were not mourned because they had never been known to most. The town’s normalcy was a blanket, warm and suffocating.
Mara walked into the city with the feeling of a person carrying a lantern through fog. She did not know whether she would find answers or whether the world outside would be kinder to memory. She only knew that she would not stop naming the people who had been taken, even if the names were spoken into a room that would not answer.
On the first night in a cheap room above a laundromat, she took out her notebook and wrote, in ink that would not fade: Eli Turner. Mrs. Kline. Jonas Reed. Asha Patel. She read the names aloud until the words felt solid. Then she slept, and in her dreams the town hummed like a clock that had been wound too tight.
In Hallowbridge, the harvest festival lights blinked and the band played on. The missing were not missed by most, and the town’s life continued, tidy and untroubled. The wrongness of it all sat like a stone at the bottom of a well—heavy, unseen, and impossible to lift.
About the Creator
Kristen Barenthaler
Curious adventurer. Crazed reader. Librarian. Archery instructor. True crime addict.
Instagram: @kristenbarenthaler
Facebook: @kbarenthaler


Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.